by Dr. Yakov Barton
Depression is often understood in purely clinical terms—a mental illness to be diagnosed, pathologized, and medicated. But what if that’s not the whole story? A growing body of psychological research, including insights from my own dissertation work and subsequent publications, suggests that not all depression is a sign of disorder. Sometimes, what we call “depression” is actually a normative, developmental process—a signal that something within us needs to shift, evolve, or grow.
Developmental Depression: A Natural Part of Transformation
Think back to times of major change: Endings, losses, career transitions, or deep disappointments. For many, these periods are marked by sadness, withdrawal, and questioning—a “low” that’s uncomfortable, but also oddly fertile. This is what my research colleagues and I have termed developmental depression. It’s less about malfunction and more about a necessary pause and introspection—a slowing down so the psyche can re-evaluate what matters, let go of what’s obsolete, and plant the seeds for something new.
My research explored this phenomenon, finding that many people who reported the most profound personal growth also experienced periods of depression not as an illness, but as a passage—a time when old identities and beliefs were stripped away, clearing the ground for deeper authenticity, creativity, or meaning. In this light, developmental depressive symptoms can be reframed as the mind’s way of signaling a need for reflection, integration, and realignment with our values and desires.
Psychological research has also explored a phenomenon known as depressive realism—the idea that people in depressed states sometimes have a more accurate perception of reality, particularly their own inner landscape. While depression can certainly distort self-worth and diminish hope, it can also strip away illusions we’ve been clinging to. In certain cases, that lowered mood opens a window of clarity, allowing us to see misalignments we’ve been avoiding, unmet needs we’ve pushed aside, or truths about our relationships, careers, or selves that we’ve long neglected. When supported skillfully in therapy, this kind of clarity can serve as the beginning of real, sustainable growth.
When Is Depression a Signal, Not a Symptom?
This perspective raises important—and sometimes controversial—questions: When is depression a “problem” to be treated, and when is it a developmental process to be supported? While clinical depression with severe, persistent symptoms absolutely warrants intervention, many experiences of low mood, loss of motivation, or emotional pain may be a normal, even healthy, response to life’s challenges.
If we rush to medicate or pathologize every experience of depression, we risk missing the deeper message it carries. The very discomfort we want to avoid may actually be what propels us toward growth. This isn’t to say medication is never appropriate—sometimes, it’s lifesaving. But the key is discernment: Are we trying to erase necessary pain, or are we supporting someone to move through it with awareness, support, and ultimately, transformation?
A Positive Psychology Lens: Depression as an Opportunity
Positive psychology invites us to look at the whole picture of human experience—not just the absence of suffering, but the presence of meaning, resilience, and fulfillment. From this view, developmental depression isn’t something to be “fixed,” but rather, a catalyst for self-discovery and positive change. When we allow ourselves to slow down and listen to the wisdom embedded in our sadness or emptiness, we open the door to genuine transformation.
In psychotherapy, this means creating space for clients to sit with and explore their depressive feelings—not just seeking to alleviate them, but to ask, “What is this experience trying to teach me? What in my life is wanting to change or grow?” The answers are rarely quick or easy, but they’re often deeply rewarding. The depressive episode, rather than being a detour, becomes a turning point.
Reframing the Conversation Around Depression
As we broaden our understanding of depression, we empower people to relate to their pain in a new way—not as a permanent state or a personal failing, but as a passage through which growth is possible. This is a more optimistic, humanizing lens—one that honors both the suffering and the potential for renewal within it.
The challenge, for clinicians and clients alike, is to discern when depression is a call for help and when it’s a call for growth. With compassion, curiosity, and the right support, periods of low mood can become opportunities for deep healing and self-renewal. Sometimes our next chapter begins not in spite of depression—but because of it.